It's a Bird. No it's a Plane...No it's a....Carrot?

Well it's a nice smooshy day here. I thought it would be an ucky day, but it's warmer than expected and I like the smell that comes with smooshy days. Smooshy is a good word. The thing that has really been on my mind though, is my new keychain. I bought it Old Navy last week and since then a heated debate has ensued. No one knows what it is!!!!! Here is a picture . There votes over what it are as follows: 1. A Round Carrot 2. A Peach 3. A Tomato 4. A Pumpkin. I know it sounds crazy but, I'm dying to know what this thing is. Please feel free to send in votes or new ideas, maybe I'll email Old Navy and see what they say it's supposed to be. Me, I still think it's a round carrot.
"If you want to know the character of a man, find out what his cat thinks of him."- Anonymous